***Hops on Soap Box***
Today one of my FB friends posted this umbrella picture. It’s not the first time I’ve seen this graphic, in fact, I usually see it every month or so.  
On one hand, it looks innocent enough.  It’s dripping in Christianese and it seems to support a complementarianism view of marriage where everyone has a role to play.  I’m all for *healthy* complementarianism (almost never seen anymore), but that is not what this graphic supports.  Instead, this graphic is quite dangerous, and even heretical.  Here’s why:
1. It obliterates the doctrine of the priesthood of believers. ALL believers have equal standing before the Father and have equal access to His throne. A woman’s mediator between herself and God the Father is the *Holy Spirit*, not her husband. 
2. Can a husband not also nurture, teach, or comfort?  Can a wife not also provide for the family and lead her children?  Marriage is about being team mates, not managers. 
3. In the most basic sense, this graphic isn’t even logical.  The only reason a second umbrella would be needed is if the above one is leaky.  Jesus doesn’t have holes in his umbrella, so there’s no need for additional umbrellas. 🙂 Photo Credit Kaytie Buckhalt
4. The umbrella diagram ultimately makes a promise that is simply false: if you stay in your place, and don’t step a toe out of this supposed authority structure, then you will not suffer attack.  This is so dangerous!!  Ladies, your husband does not protect you from Satan or pain.  He is an imperfect person!  Only one thing offers protection and that’s JESUS.  Even then, as C.S. Lewis eloquently penned, “He is not safe. But He is good.”  We have got to stop thinking of Jesus as this magic genie that grants our wishes and makes life all happy and pain free if we’re good enough and if there is suffering going on in our life that must mean we are out of authority and that God is punishing us.  Jesus NEVER promised protection from earthly pain.  He simply promised that He would walk beside us through the pain, and ultimately, there were be good in the midst of it.
5. Jesus never talked about hiding under hypothetical umbrellas.  You know what He talked about?  Armor.  The Sword of the Spirit. The Shield of Faith.  The Helmet of Salvation.  This is our protection!  Not another flawed human being.  Not some stereotypical view of gender roles.  Jesus is our armor — our tool to fight the good fight.  
So maybe instead of umbrellas we should focus on armor and understanding that battles are messy and difficult, and you can still get injured.  But that ultimately, we will win the battle against Satan because Jesus already defeated him 2,000 years ago.

Credit for Jesus Umbrella Drawing : Kaytie Buckhalt
Credit for Dragon and Knight Cartoon: Josh Stallar

1 Comment

  1. You are being quoted as saying that the pic attached is attributed to IBLP. Can you show me where this is true? I have books and workbooks here because I’ve taken their training and lived that life and I can’t find anything close. TIA
    I can’t get the pic of the info to attach. It talks about why God allowed a four year old to be molested and has five points under it. Did that come from you? Are those five points written in their material? I’d like to see it if it is.
    Emily Elizabeth Anderson AUTHOR  05/12/2021 03:49 PM Central
    Hi Janet,

    This exact picture is not from Gothard, but he was the one to first create the "Umbrella of Protection/Authority" diagram. It is explained in The Basic Seminar and throughout his Wisdom Booklets.

    I did write on FB about the material titled, "Why Did God Allow a Four Year Old to Be Molested". That came out of a Gothard counseling seminar from the 90's. You can read more by clicking on the link.


Leave a Comment